Colonial domination had various effects, such as the formal
abolition of slavery in the years preceding World War II,
particularly in the interriverine area. The effects of Western rule
had a greater impact on the social and economic orders in urban than
in rural areas. After World War II, the institution of the
trusteeship in the Italian-administered south and greater attention
to education in the British-run north gradually led to further
change.
The late colonial period and the first decade of independence saw
the decline, in part legally enforced, of caste-like restrictions and
impediments to the equality of habash and traditional
occupational groups. In the south, although nobles were more likely
to take advantage of educational opportunities, habash
increasingly did so.
The growing importance of manual skills in the modern economy gave
some occupational groups an economic, if not an immediate social,
advantage. For example, many Tumaal blacksmiths became mechanics and
settled in towns. In southern port towns, carpenters, weavers, and
other artisans formed guilds to protect their common interests. As
skilled manual work became more available and socially acceptable,
tolerance of members of the traditional groups increased to the point
where some intermarriage occurred in the towns. In the rural areas,
members of these groups formed their own diya-paying units and
in a few cases began to take part in the councils of the Somali
lineages to which they remained attached.
Somali leaders tried to eliminate the traditional disabilities of
low-status groups. In early 1960, just before independence, the
legislative assembly of the Italian trust territory abolished the
status of client, that is, of habash dependent on Somalis for
land and water rights. The law stated that Somali citizens could live
and farm where they chose, independent of hereditary affiliation.
Patron lineages in the riverine area resisted the change and
retaliated against habash assertions of independence. They
withheld customary farming and watering rights, excluded habash
from diya-paying arrangements, and, in some cases, sought to
oust them from the land they had farmed for generations as clients.
Some habash brought cases in court, seeking to affirm their
new rights, but initially many continued to live under the old
arrangements. Clientship appeared by the early 1990s to have
diminished in fact as it had been abrogated in law.
Whereas some features of traditional stratification were eroded,
new strata based on education and command of a foreign
language--English or Italian--were forming in the late colonial
period. With independence, a new elite arose as Somalis assumed the
highest political and bureaucratic positions in national government.
A subelite also emerged, consisting of persons with more modest
educational qualifications who filled posts in local and regional
government. In many cases, however, these government workers were the
sons of men who had acquired a degree of wealth in nonprofessional
activities such as landholding, trading, and herding, in part because
the costs of secondary education in the colonial period could be met
only by relatively affluent families.
Two somewhat contradictory forces affected educated urban Somalis
in the 1950s and 1960s. On the one hand their income, education, and,
above all, their literacy in a foreign language distanced them from
most other Somalis. On the other hand, lineage and clan remained
important to most of this new elite. Thus descent groups acquired a
new importance in national politics.
Locally, particularly in the larger towns, a combination of
outsiders and area residents provided middle-level administration.
One administrative component would consist of members of the national
subelite brought in by the Somali government. Typically, this group
would include the district commissioner, the judge, the secretary to
the municipality, the staff of some of these officials, teachers, and
the national police. Locally elected councillors would constitute the
other administrative component. Some councillors were lineage heads;
others were businessmen or had some other basis for their local
status. Some of the local notables had sons serving as district
officials but, by regulation, not in their home communities. In
Afgooye, a town in which the Geledi, the Wadaan (a group of the
Hawiye clan-family), and others were represented, the local people
and the subelite meshed well in the mid- and late 1960s, but Afgooye
was not necessarily representative of local communities in the
riverine areas or elsewhere.
Beginning in the nineteenth century, there was a growing
distinction between the bulk of nomadic Somalis and their kinsmen in
the towns acting as middlemen in the livestock trade with Aden. Some
of these townsmen became relatively wealthy and appeared to have more
influence in council than their pastoralist relatives.
By the 1960s, the demand for livestock in the Middle East had led
to a great expansion of the livestock trade through the port of
Berbera. Hargeysa and Burao became the points from which 150 to 200
major livestock dealers and their agents--all but a few of them
Somalis--operated. The nomadic producers directed their activity
toward the commercial market, but the traders controlled the terms of
trade, the feedlots, and some of the better grazing land. The
government did not interfere because the livestock trade was too
important as a source of foreign exchange, and because the traders
marketed the animals efficiently.
A new class of merchants thus emerged. They retained their
connections with their lineages, but their interests differed from
those of nomadic herders. If they were not educated, they tried to
ensure that their children attended school.
After World War II and during the first decade of independence,
the government stressed loyalty to the nation in place of loyalty to
clan and lineage. The segmental system was seen as a divisive force,
a source of nepotism and corruption; Somali politicians denounced it
as "tribalism." A few Somalis rejected reference to clan and lineage.
Nevertheless, persons meeting for the first time asked each other
about their "ex- clans." Clan-families, once functionally
unimportant, became increasingly significant as political rallying
points, particularly as Somalia approached independence, and they
continued to be so in the 1990s. Clans and lineages remained the
basic unit of society, serving many social, political, and economic
functions regionally and locally. Although the Somali government
opposed clans and lineages, it continued to appoint and pay lineage
heads; lineages and clans were in fact voting blocs. Supreme Court
decisions in 1962 and 1964 effected a major change in the role of the
diya-paying group. The court's judgments forbade collective
payment for premeditated homicide. Payments for unpremeditated
homicide and injury, however, were defined as compensation for a tort
and were permitted. In this era, too, the diya-paying group's
responsibilities were extended to cover traffic fatalities.
The military leadership that took power in October 1969 introduced
elements that constituted a radical break with the past. The new
regime soon declared socialism as its frame of reference, in part as
a means of obtaining Soviet aid. The regime's basic ideas constituted
a pragmatic version of Marxism adapted to local social and economic
conditions. In this version, class struggle did not apply; the
bourgeoisie was very small, composed of the new elite and subelite
(chiefly employed in government), a few traders, and a few
professionals. There was no significant proletariat, rural or urban,
and no great Somali entrepreneurs or landholders.
In its initial zest for change, the new regime focused on the
divisions in Somali society: the cleavages between clans and
lineages, the settled and the nomadic, strong and weak pastoral
lineages competing for grazing and water, patrons and clients in the
cultivating regions, and urban and rural dwellers. Attention was also
given to the continuing disdain shown to those of low status. Under
the new regime, clan and lineage affiliations were irrelevant to
social relations, and the use of pejorative labels to describe
specific groups thought inferior to Somalis were forbidden. All
Somalis were asked to call each other jaalle (comrade),
regardless of hereditary affiliation.
Within limits the language of public discourse can be changed by
fiat; much pejorative language was expurgated. Nevertheless, Somalis
continued to learn each other's clan or lineage affiliation when it
was useful to do so, and in private it was not uncommon for Somalis
to refer to habash by the phrase "kinky hair." The term
jaalle was widely used in the media and in a range of public
situations, but its use cannot be said to have reflected a change of
perspective.
The government also sought to change the function of the clans and
lineages by abolishing the title of elder and replacing it
with peacekeeper. Peacekeepers were the appointed spokesmen of
what were officially regarded as local groups composed of either
cultivators or pastoralists. In the early 1970s, collective
responsibility (diya payment) in any guise was abolished.
Like most governments required to deal with a large nomadic
population, the pre- and post-revolutionary regimes sought to find
ways to settle the pastoralists, both to improve the pastoral economy
and to facilitate control and services. Efforts to convert the nomads
into ranchers made little progress, and in the early 1990s most
herders were still nomadic or seminomadic. The 1974 drought, however,
drove many nomads to seek government help; by 1975 about 105,000 had
been resettled, 90,000 as cultivators and 15,000 as fishermen. Clans
were deliberately mixed within the settlements, and the settlers were
expected to deal as individuals with local councils, committees, and
courts, whose membership was also heterogeneous. Three years later,
nearly 45 percent of the adult males had left the cultivating
settlements, perhaps to resume herding. Most of those living in
fishing communities remained. Neither the farmers nor the fishermen
had been economically successful.
The dismantling of the diya system; the institution of
several political and administrative offices intended to eliminate
power vested in lineages and clans; and the establishment of
committees, councils, and cooperatives were all part of a policy to
replace the descent group system as the primary means of organizing
political, economic, and social life. Another manifestation of this
policy was the banning in 1972 of weddings, burials, and religious
rites organized on a lineage or clan basis. Wedding ceremonies were
henceforth to be held at orientation centers or other public places.
Money could not be collected from lineage members for the burial of a
dead member, and the law forbade religious rites tied to local
traditions.
Most published observations refer to the continuing role of clan
affiliation in national politics. The clan-family, which rose to
considerable importance in Somali politics in the 1950s and 1960s,
seemed in later years to lose its force as a rallying point. With the
exception of northern Somalia's Isaaq people, the groups that exerted
influence either for or against the regime were mostly of a single
clan-family, the Daarood; President Mohammed Siad Barre's clan,
Mareehaan; his mother's clan, Ogaden; his son-in-law's clan,
Dulbahante; and the opposition clan, Majeerteen.
Among the revolutionary regime's concerns was the status of women.
After World War II, all political parties had established women's
committees. In the Italian-administered south, women voted for the
first time in the 1958 municipal elections; in the formerly British
north, women voted in the 1961 national referendum on the
constitution. Women's role in public affairs remained minimal,
however, and little was done to change their legal situation in the
first decade of independence.
Under Somali customary law, a woman was under the legal protection
of a male--her father or husband, or one of their kinsmen in the
event of their deaths. In blood compensation, her life was usually
valued at half that of a man. Islamic law permitted daughters to
inherit half of what was inherited by sons, but in Somali practice
daughters ordinarily did not share in the inheritance of valued
property (camels or land). Few girls attended school and even fewer
continued beyond the elementary level.
The revolutionary government quickly changed women's legal and
political status. In principle, the question of diya payment
for injuries to women became moot following the formal termination of
the traditional system. Soon after the revolution, the government
established committees to deal with women's affairs. Women also began
participating in government, committees, sports, and other social and
cultural activities. In early 1975, Siad Barre announced a decision
by the Supreme Revolutionary Council (SRC) and the Council of
Ministers to give equal rights to women in several respects,
including equal inheritance rights, a move that led to protests by
some Islamic leaders. Perhaps more important was the government's
insistence that girls attend school, particularly beyond the
elementary level.
There were women in visible public posts in Somalia in 1990. Until
the 1991 collapse of the state, 6 of the 171 elected members of the
People's Assembly were women. Increasing numbers of females were
attending secondary school and university. Further progress for women
was interrupted by the civil war and would have to await
reconstruction of the country.
The Siad Barre government also acted in the economic sphere,
fostering various government agencies at the national, regional, and
local levels. The regime initiated some enterprises and placed others
under state control. Much productive and distributive enterprise
remained in private hands, however.
In the rural areas, the government (beginning with colonial
administrations) and large-scale private farmers had acquired much of
the irrigated land. In the late 1970s, small-scale farmers had worked
some of the irrigated land and much of the flood land, but by the
mid-1980s much of the latter had been converted to controlled
irrigation and had come under state control. For the most part,
rain-fed land cultivation remained in the hands of traditional
smallholders engaged in subsistence farming, some of whom earned the
cash they needed by working on state farms. Most extensions of the
irrigation system facilitated development of large state farms,
rather than small farms. Some rural Somalis held no land and relied
on wage labor on state farms and large private holdings (chiefly
banana plantations) for their livelihood.
Under Siad Barre's regime, animal husbandry remained primarily in
the hands of individual pastoral Somalis. The chief change lay in the
readiness of these pastoralists to sell their livestock in response
to overseas demand. Marketing was in the hands of private traders who
had accumulated enough capital to construct water storage units and
invest in a transport fleet. In addition, a number of traders had
enclosed rangeland to produce hay, thereby excluding herders who
formerly had used the land. These traders benefited not only from the
government construction of roads and other facilities but also from
arrangements whereby their overseas earnings might be used in part to
buy imports for domestic sale.
Although income distinctions existed among Somalis in the private
sphere, until 1991 those who combined comparatively large incomes
with reasonable security were government employees such as
administrators, technical personnel, and managers of state- owned
enterprises. As under the first independence regime, administrators
did not serve in their home territories and were therefore not linked
by kinship to the more affluent Somalis in the local private sector.
Despite the otherwise fluid character of the system, the apex of
the local hierarchy in a rural settled area consisted of the
high-level (and to some extent the middle-level) representatives of
the state. These included regional and local administrators, managers
of state farms and agro-industries such as the sugar refinery at
Giohar, technicians, and highly skilled workers. Members of this
group had relatively high incomes and could be reasonably sure of
seeing that their children finished school, an important prerequisite
to finding a good position. Because they often determined the flow of
resources to the private sector, this elite group exercised economic
power greater than that of wealthy merchants or large landholders
whose income might be the same as, or larger than, theirs.
At the bottom of the economic hierarchy were most rural Somalis,
whether sedentary or nomadic. Living primarily by subsistence
cropping or herding, they sold what they could. They had little
contact with government and had been relatively untouched by
development projects because of their isolation or insufficient
government efforts to reach them. The farmers among them cultivated
the poorest land and barely earned survival incomes with wage work.
The pastoralists were most affected by the demands of a difficult
environment. Beginning in the late 1970s, limits on migration
resulting from hostile relations between Somalia and Ethiopia caused
them additional hardship.
As of the early 1990s, two other significant categories of rural
residents were workers whose wages derived from state-owned or
state-sponsored activities, and landholders or herders who operated
on a smaller scale than the plantation owners. Neither of these
categories was homogeneous. Wage workers ranged from landless and
relatively unskilled agricultural workers whose income might be
intermittent, to low-level workers in government agencies whose
income was likely to be steadier and who might be heads of or members
of families with subsistence farms or herds. Plots or herds owned by
farmers or herders varied considerably in size and quality, as did
the income derived from them. Nevertheless farmers and herders fared
better than subsistence farmers. They joined cooperatives, took
advantage of adult education, and participated in government programs
that promised to enhance their incomes and the status of the next
generation. Members of this category sent their children to school
and arranged for some of them to seek more lucrative or prestigious
employment in Mogadishu or other large towns.
Rural petty traders did not clearly belong to any one economic
category. Their incomes were not large, but equaled those of many
lower-level wage workers and small-scale market- oriented farmers.
Particularly in Mogadishu, the national capital and the largest
town, another social pattern developed prior to the fall of the Siad
Barre regime. Because of their incomes and the power they wielded,
the highest party and government officials became the new apex of
Somali society. In the early 1990s, the salaries and allowances of
cabinet ministers were twice that of the next highest officials, the
directors general of ministries, and nearly twenty-five times that of
the lowest levels of the civil service. Below the ministers and
directors general but well above the clerks of the bureaucracy were
other high-level administrators, executives, and skilled personnel.
For instance, the manager of a large state-owned factory earned
somewhat less than a minister but more than a director general. An
unskilled laborer in a state farm earned less than the poorest-paid
civil servant, but an unskilled worker in a factory earned a little
more. Unskilled farm and factory workers and bottom-level government
employees earned only 5 to 10 percent of a manager's salary.
As in the rural areas, in the towns there were many people
involved in the private sector. In some respects, merchants and
traders had the deepest urban roots. Most of them were petty traders
and shopkeepers whose income and status were closer to those of
craftsmen than to those of the wealthier merchants.
In the mid-1970s, a manufacturing census indicated that about
6,000 enterprises in Somalia employed five or fewer persons, most of
them probably family members. Unlike the larger, often foreign-owned
industrial concerns, these had not been nationalized.
Most urban dwellers were wage workers, but they had various
skills, sources of employment, and incomes. For example, low- and
middle-level clerks in the government bureaucracy and in state
enterprises earned no more (and sometimes less) than skilled artisans
in state firms, and both earned perhaps twice as much as unskilled
factory laborers.
The situation of the urban population had changed radically by
early 1992. Following the fall of Siad Barre, urban areas consisted
largely of refugees or war victims who had migrated from the
countryside after the civil war began.